Rows 1 to 2 — the road
Whether the tool understands that a road has a height, a weight rating and a turn radius, and refuses to send a 13-foot-6 trailer under a 13-foot bridge.
Compare
Twenty-four rows across six categories, including the rows where our own column is a plain no. Anything a vendor has not published is marked not published rather than scored against them.
The matrix
These are category generalisations rather than vendor claims. Individual products inside a category vary, and the category pages name them one by one.
Showing all 24 capabilities.
| Capability | AxleGuard | Routing & navigation | Dispatch / TMS | Telematics / ELD | Onboard scales | Bypass & permits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Truck-aware route requested from stored dimensions and weight | Yes | Yes | part | No | No | No |
| Low bridges and restricted roads avoided on the planAxleGuard marks the route for manual review if the provider relaxes a restriction | part | Yes | part | No | No | No |
| Per-axle weight solved from cargo positionBefore anything is loaded | Yes | No | No | No | No | No |
| Bridge formula on every consecutive axle group | Yes | No | No | No | part | No |
| Tire and axle-rating limits layered on statute | Yes | No | No | No | No | No |
| Which rule bound, named on the verdict | Yes | No | No | No | No | No |
| Corrective slider position in holes and inches | Yes | No | No | No | No | No |
| Answer available before the trailer is sealed | Yes | part | part | No | No | No |
| Compliance recomputed per leg as freight comes off | Yes | No | No | No | No | No |
| Fuel burn changing the verdict mid-trip | Yes | No | No | No | part | No |
| Restriction-ignored warning surfaced to the planner | Yes | part | No | No | No | No |
| Derived replay now; physical axle signal after commissioning | part | No | No | part | Yes | No |
| Weight history plotted across the whole runCurrent AxleGuard samples are a named derived replay; physical measurements require commissioning | Yes | No | No | part | part | No |
| HOS planning clocks on the same timeline as the loadPlanning arithmetic, separate from the legal log-of-record workflow | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | No | No |
| Editable jurisdiction rule sets | Yes | No | part | No | No | part |
| Permit pathway when no legal position existsIdentifies candidates and tracks the filing record; the issuing agency still controls the permit | Yes | No | part | No | No | Yes |
| Escort and travel-window conditions recorded on a permitAxleGuard records the controlling conditions; it does not derive or issue them | part | No | part | No | No | part |
| Weigh station and bypass status along the route | part | No | No | part | No | Yes |
| HOS record workflow and roadside transferNot an FMCSA-registered ELD; telematic/local transfer unlocks only when registration evidence is recorded | part | No | part | Yes | No | No |
| Orders, rates, settlements and invoicing | No | No | Yes | No | No | No |
| Hardware fitted to the truck required | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | part |
| Provider cost linked to the individual loadThe call record can carry a load ID; the current report does not aggregate a per-load ledger | part | No | part | part | No | part |
| Before-and-after audit on governed changes | Yes | No | part | No | No | No |
| The same verdict on the desk and in the cab | Yes | part | part | part | part | No |
Read a part as "some products in this category, or all of them with limits". Read an n/p as "the vendors we checked have not published this", which is a fact about documentation and not a fault.
Our column was checked against the application code
How to read it
A tick in the wrong group is worth nothing. A fleet that already routes well and still gets cited has a problem in rows three to seven, not in rows one and two.
Whether the tool understands that a road has a height, a weight rating and a turn radius, and refuses to send a 13-foot-6 trailer under a 13-foot bridge.
Whether the tool solves what each axle group carries from where the freight sits, applies every statutory test to it, and says which rule bound.
Whether the answer survives contact with a real trip: legs, drops, fuel burn, hours, and a verdict that changes because the truck moved.
Whether jurisdiction is a property of the load rather than a global setting, and what happens when no legal position exists.
The office functions, the hardware, the money and the audit trail. This is where our own column has the honest gaps in it.
Orders, settlements and invoicing remain a plain no. HOS record mechanics exist, but the workspace is not FMCSA registered. Recorded registration status gates transfer today; the other readiness checks are visible evidence, not yet enforcement gates. Physical signals stay partial until a real gateway passes commissioning.
Plus six part, and two plain no
Plus three part
Plus ten part
Plus five part
Plus four part
Plus four part
Counted from the table above. This is not a scoreboard. The twenty-four rows follow one load from planning through operation, and every category here is being asked about work it may never have set out to do.
A dispatch system carrying two ticks and ten parts is not a weak product. It is a strong product being asked about axle physics. Read down the rows that bind your own operation instead, and ignore the totals.
Five of these six columns hold products a fleet already owns. The question was never which one to replace.
The nearest neighbours
Putting a dedicated axle weight calculator in the same column as a dispatch system would flatter us and mislead you. This is the closer comparison, and the one worth arguing about.
Showing all 12 capabilities.
| Capability | AxleGuard | Axle weight calculators | Load and container packers | Spreadsheet built in-house |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Axle weights from payload position | Yes | Yes | part | part |
| Bridge formula on every consecutive group | Yes | part | No | No |
| Tire and axle-rating limits layered on statute | Yes | n/p | No | No |
| Corrective move given in holes and inches | Yes | No | No | No |
| Jurisdiction rule set attached to the load | Yes | part | No | No |
| Container and pallet packing in three dimensions | Yes | No | Yes | No |
| Centre of gravity and stability output | part | Yes | Yes | No |
| Finished-vehicle build record and sign-off workflow | part | Yes | No | No |
| Re-solved per leg as freight comes off | Yes | No | No | No |
| Routed on a road the vehicle can legally take | Yes | No | No | No |
| Derived replay now; physical axle signal after commissioning | part | No | No | No |
| Audit trail of who changed a limit | Yes | n/p | n/p | No |
Two engineering boundaries
Methodology
Every row is drawn from publicly published product documentation, specification sheets and vendor support material, read as of August 2026. Where a vendor does not publish a capability, the cell reads not published. That is a statement about what has been written down, not a claim that the product cannot do it.
There are no pricing figures, customer counts, market share numbers or benchmark timings anywhere in this table, because we have not run those tests and the vendors have not published figures that could be compared fairly.
Product names and trademarks belong to their owners and are used for identification and comparison only. None of the vendors named on this site has reviewed or endorsed any of it. These are active products that ship changes continuously, so confirm anything that matters directly with the vendor before it decides a purchase.
The reasoning behind each row, category by category, is on themethodology section of the compare hub.
One table is not a decision
Where a row disagrees with a vendor
Six rows carry visible limits: relaxed route restrictions, physical signals, permit conditions, bypass, HOS transfer and per-load cost presentation. Orders and invoicing remain outside the product.
Category detail
Every category page names the products, says what each one is good at, and marks anything the vendor has not published.
Back to the landscapeRouting and navigation
Five platforms that know the road, and the question they are not asked.
ReadAxle and load calculators
The nearest neighbours we have, and what a desk tool cannot reach.
ReadDispatch and TMS
Six systems that run a freight company properly.
ReadTelematics and ELD
The best record of the truck, arriving after the fact.
ReadOnboard scales
Real measurement, once the freight is already aboard.
ReadBypass and permits
The interface with enforcement, and what a green light means.
ReadNext step
Pick the four rows your operation actually lives on, bring a real load, and see whether our column holds up on your freight rather than on our page.